Support Chiropractic Research!

Diagnosis

Chiropractic Students Versus Emergency Care Practitioners in Simulated Musculoskeletal Emergencies

By |November 11, 2025|All About Chiropractic, Care Plans, Cervical Disk Herniation, Chiropractic Education, Chiropractic Management, Diagnosis, Escalation of Care, Evidence-based Medicine|

Chiropractic Students Versus Emergency Care Practitioners in Simulated Musculoskeletal Emergencies

The Chiro.Org Blog


SOURCE:   Health SA 2025 (Oct 31): 30: 3195


Ivanna Balanco • Helen Slabber • Christopher Yelverton

Department of Chiropractic,
Faculty of Health Sciences,
University of Johannesburg,
Johannesburg, South Africa.


Background:   As primary contact practitioners, chiropractors and emergency care practitioners (ECPs are first points of access for patients with musculoskeletal (MSK) complaints. A comparison of their diagnostic competency in distinguishing these presentations from underlying emergency pathologies remains an understudied area.

Aim:   To compare the diagnostic abilities of Master of Health Science (MHSc) chiropractic students and ECPs in distinguishing MSK from emergency conditions.

Setting:   The research was conducted at the University of Johannesburg, Faculty of Health Sciences, simulation laboratory.

Methods:   First-year (n = 10) and second-year Master’s (n = 10) chiropractic students and ECPs (n = 10) were assessed using standardised patient scenarios: meningitis, disc herniation and stroke, and assessed on diagnostic assessment, diagnosis and clinical and diagnostic investigation referrals.

Results:   Second-year MHSc students outperformed ECPs in the clinical management of a disc herniation case (Case 2; p < 0.01). Diagnostic accuracy was high (> 90%) for meningitis and stroke across all groups. Differences in investigation preferences emerged, with chiropractic students favouring advanced imaging and ECPs recommending more basic tests. No significant performance differences were found in the other two cases.

Conclusion:   Based on a simulated assessment, chiropractic students demonstrated equivalent competence to emergency care practitioners (ECPs) in diagnosing emergencies, but outperformed them in managing an MSK condition. These preliminary findings suggest chiropractors could contribute to the management of MSK burden in emergency departments.

Contribution:   MHSc chiropractic training enhances diagnostic proficiency in differentiating MSK disorders from emergent pathologies, an important competency for safe and effective practice as primary contact practitioners.

Keywords:   chiropractic; clinical competence; diagnosis; emergency medical services; musculoskeletal disease; simulation.


From the FULL TEXT Article:

Introduction

Musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions represent a significant global health burden, ranking as the second leading cause of disability worldwide and affecting approximately one in five working-age adults (Lowe, Taylor & Hill 2017; Weinstein 2016). Back pain, a prevalent MSK complaint, contributes substantially to reduced work productivity, absenteeism and healthcare costs (Ingram & Symmons 2018; Menke 2003). This high prevalence strains healthcare systems, leading to long wait times for specialist care, including surgery (Joshipura & Gosselin 2020).

There are more articles like this @

ALL ABOUT CHIROPRACTIC Section

(more…)

Diagnostic and Treatment Methods Used by Chiropractors

By |February 14, 2019|Diagnosis|

Diagnostic and Treatment Methods Used by Chiropractors: A Random Sample Survey of Canada’s English-speaking Provinces

The Chiro.Org Blog


SOURCE:   J Can Chiropr Assoc. 2015 (Sep); 59 (3): 279–287

Aaron A. Puhl, MSc, DC, Christine J Reinhart, PhD, DC, and H. Stephen Injeyan, PhD, DC

Department of Pathology and Microbiology,
Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College,
Toronto, ON, M2H 3J1


OBJECTIVE:   It is important to understand how chiropractors practice beyond their formal education. The objective of this analysis was to assess the diagnostic and treatment methods used by chiropractors in English-speaking Canadian provinces.

METHODS:   A questionnaire was created that examined practice patterns amongst chiropractors. This was sent by mail to 749 chiropractors, randomly selected and stratified proportionally across the nine English-speaking Canadian provinces. Participation was voluntary and anonymous. Data were entered into an Excel spreadsheet, and descriptive statistics were calculated.

RESULTS:   The response rate was 68.0%. Almost all (95.1%) of respondents reported performing differential diagnosis procedures with their new patients; most commonly orthopaedic testing, palpation, history taking, range of motion testing and neurological examination. Palpation and painful joint findings were the most commonly used methods to determine the appropriate joint to apply manipulation. The most common treatment methods were manual joint manipulation/mobilization, stretching and exercise, posture/ergonomic advice and soft-tissue therapies.

There are more articles like this @ our:

CHIROPRACTIC SUBLUXATION Page

(more…)

Plasmacytoma of the Cervical Spine

By |December 7, 2017|Diagnosis|

Plasmacytoma of the Cervical Spine: A Case Study

The Chiro.Org Blog


SOURCE:   J Chiropractic Medicine 2017 (Jun); 16 (2): 170–174


Richard Pashayan, DC, DABCO, CCSP,
Wesley M. Cavanaugh, DC,
Chad D. Warshel, DC, DACBR, and
David R. Payne, MD

Private Practice,
Flushing, NY.


OBJECTIVE:   The purpose of this case study is to describe the presentation of a patient with plasmacytoma.

CLINICAL FEATURES:   A 49-year-old man presented with progressive neck pain, stiffness, and dysphagia to a chiropractic office. A radiograph indicated a plasmacytoma at C3 vertebral body. The lesion was expansile and caused a mass effect anteriorly on the esophagus and posteriorly on the spinal cord. Neurologic compromise was noted with fasciculations and hypesthesia in the right forearm. The patient was referred to a neurosurgeon.

INTERVENTION AND OUTCOME:   Surgical resection of the tumor was performed with a vertebral body spacer and surrounding titanium cage. Bony fusion was initiated by inserting bone grafts from the iliac crests into the titanium cage. Additional laboratory analysis and advanced imaging confirmed that the plasmacytoma had progressed to multiple myeloma and radiation and chemotherapy were also necessary.

There are other articles like this @ our:

Case Reports Section

(more…)

Chiropractic Gains Ground During Texas Legislative Session

By |June 1, 2017|Diagnosis|

Chiropractic Gains Ground During Texas Legislative Session

The Chiro.Org Blog


SOURCE:  Texas Chiropractic Association ~ May 30, 2017


Texas Gov. Greg Abbott signed into law Senate Bill 304, continuing the Texas Board of Chiropractic Examiners (TBCE) and upholding the right of licensed doctors of chiropractic in Texas to diagnose patients. It caps a historic legislative session for the chiropractic profession in Texas.

The Texas Board of Chiropractic Examiners is a state agency that regulates the chiropractic profession in Texas. Along with other state health care agencies, TBCE was under review by the Texas Sunset Advisory Commission last year. With the governor’s signature, the state’s chiropractic board will continue through Sept. 1, 2029, in addition to several other modifications to increase patient safety.

Also included in the bill was specific language to be incorporated into the Texas Chiropractic Act that clarifies the right of Texas chiropractors to diagnose. This nullifies a 2016 decision by the Travis County District Court in the Texas Medical Association vs. Texas Board of Chiropractic Examiners law suit in which diagnosis was deemed to exceed the scope of practice. With the signing of Senate Bill 304, the matter of diagnosis is settled.

“If the district court’s ruling had been allowed to stand, Texas would have been the only state in which chiropractors are not allowed to diagnose,” said Tyce Hergert, DC, of Grapevine, Texas, president of the Texas Chiropractic Association (TCA) and a chiropractor who practices in Southlake, Texas. “Without this right, it would endanger patient safety and potentially affect insurance reimbursement. We thank the governor for recognizing the importance of this issue and creating greater access to chiropractic care for the citizens of Texas.”

TCA is awaiting the governor’s signature on two other key bills:

There are background articles about the Texas Diagnosis battle @ our:

Prescription Rights and Expanded Practice Page

(more…)

Mechanisms of Low Back Pain: A Guide for Diagnosis and Therapy

By |October 30, 2016|Diagnosis, Low Back Pain|

Mechanisms of Low Back Pain: A Guide for Diagnosis and Therapy

The Chiro.Org Blog


SOURCE:   F1000Res. 2016 (Oct 11); 5. pii: F1000


Massimo Allegri, Silvana Montella, Fabiana Salici,
Adriana Valente, Maurizio Marchesini, Christian Compagnone,
Marco Baciarello, Maria Elena Manferdini, and Guido Fanelli

Department of Surgical Sciences,
University of Parma,
Parma, Italy


Chronic low back pain (CLBP) is a chronic pain syndrome in the lower back region, lasting for at least 3 months. CLBP represents the second leading cause of disability worldwide being a major welfare and economic problem. The prevalence of CLBP in adults has increased more than 100% in the last decade and continues to increase dramatically in the aging population, affecting both men and women in all ethnic groups, with a significant impact on functional capacity and occupational activities. It can also be influenced by psychological factors, such as stress, depression and/or anxiety. Given this complexity, the diagnostic evaluation of patients with CLBP can be very challenging and requires complex clinical decision-making.

Answering the question “what is the pain generatoramong the several structures potentially involved in CLBP is a key factor in the management of these patients, since a mis-diagnosis can generate therapeutical mistakes. Traditionally, the notion that the etiology of 80% to 90% of LBP cases is unknown has been mistaken perpetuated across decades. In most cases, low back pain can be attributed to specific pain generator, with its own characteristics and with different therapeutical opportunity. Here we discuss about radicular pain, facet joint pain, sacro-iliac pain, pain related to lumbar stenosis, discogenic pain. Our article aims to offer to the clinicians a simple guidance to identify pain generators in a safer and faster way, relying a correct diagnosis and further therapeutical approach.

There are more articles like this @ our:

Low Back Pain and Chiropractic Page

(more…)

Life-Threatening Lower Back Pain

By |January 8, 2016|Diagnosis, Low Back Pain|

Life-Threatening Lower Back Pain – Decoding the Mystery Step-By-Step

The Chiro.Org Blog


SOURCE:   A Chiro.Org Contribution


David J Schimp DC, DACNB, DAAPM, FICCN and
Stefanie Krupp DC, MS

David J Schimp DC
Schimp Office of Chiropractic Professionals LTD
937 E. Sumner St.
Hartford, WI 53027 USA


This article will help clinicians identify life-threatening conditions that present with lower back pain.


Intra-abdominal bleed (e.g. aortic aneurysm), infection and tumor are the most dangerous causes of lower back pain and carry the potential for devastating consequences.

Table 1 identifies red flags that should raise suspicion of a serious disorder. [1]

Other red flags that are less likely to be associated with a life-threatening condition but that still warrant prompt diagnosis and appropriate management include:

  • pain that is worse with coughing
  • incontinence of bowel or bladder
  • urinary retention (inability to void or empty the bladder completely)
  • impotence
  • saddle anesthesia
  • intractable radicular pain into the lower extremity
  • rapidly progressive neurological deficit

The latter findings are common among patients with lumbar nerve root compression or cauda equina syndrome. Although serious, these disorders are seldom life threatening.


Step 1 –   Evaluate for Red Flags*

Table 1:   Red Flags of Low Back Pain   [1]

RED FLAGS
BLEED
INFECTION
TUMOR
1.   Duration greater than 6 weeks
X
X
2.   Age less than 18y
X
X
3.   Age greater than 50y
X
X
X
4.   Prior history of cancer
X
5.   Fever, chills or night sweats
X
X
6.   Weight loss (unexplained)
X
X
7.   IV drug use
X
8.   Recent surgical procedure
X
9.   Night pain
X
X
10.   Unremitting, constant, no relief
X
X
X
11.   Concomitant abdominal pain
X
X
X
12.   Lightheaded, weak, diaphoretic, disorientated
X

*   This is a list of red flags that may be associated with a life-threatening disease.

It is not meant to include all the other red flags of lower back pain.


Step 1:   Evaluate for Red Flags   (Discussion)

  1. Duration greater than 6 weeks.   Intractable or progressive lower back pain lasting longer than 6 weeks should raise suspicion of a serious underlying condition. Radiographs (lumbar plain film series including coronal, sagittal and spot views) and routine laboratory studies will add a greater level of diagnostic accuracy to the evaluation. Basic laboratory studies to consider include comprehensive metabolic panel, complete blood count (CBC), C-reactive protein(CRP) or high sensitivity CRP (preferred), erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) and urinalysis (UA). [2]If imaging and lab studies are normal and the patient has normal vitals, then serious disease is unlikely. Advanced imaging (MRI or CT) can be utilized if plain film radiography if felt to lack sensitivity. In the absence of serious disease, a mechanical lesion, central sensitization or psychosocial co-morbidities may explain on-going pain over 6 weeks in duration.
  2. Age less than 18 years.   Persistent pain in a pediatric patient is a red flag for tumor or infection if symptoms cannot be ascribed to a congenital abnormality or acute injury. Advanced imaging (MRI) and routine laboratory studies as noted above should be considered. 
  3. Age greater than 50 years.   Although low back pain is common in this population, clinicians should be particularly alert to the patient that presents with a new onset of low back pain, whether or not a mechanical basis is identified. Intra-abdominal disorders (e.g. abdominal aortic aneurysm) and cancer are more common in this population. Although a mechanical lesion is more likely, older patients require a greater level of diligence to rule out serious disease.(see Table 1)
  4. Patient history of cancer.   Neoplasm involving the spine may present as unrelenting pain (i.e. does not improve with rest or analgesia) or pain that is worse at night. Cancer recurrence or metastasis to the spine should be considered when a patient with a prior history of cancer complains of unrelenting back pain. Advanced imaging (MRI) is valuable and early use may be appropriate if the index of suspicion is high. Basic laboratory testing can be helpful (e.g., elevation of alkaline phosphatase on a comprehensive metabolic panel and leukocytosis on a complete blood count). [2] A history of prior malignancy is the most informative of the all the red flags listed in Table 1 and may suggest active neoplasm as the cause of the individual’s back pain. (more…)